Monday, July 11, 2011

Cookie tales

I'm not really much of a treats person. That's not to say I don't like treats, but rather that I don't tend to eat them very often. Which, let's face it, is a crying shame.

Well, okay. Let me rephrase: By "not very often" I mean, "not every day." And by "not every day" I mean that there is at least one treat that I enjoy at the very least on a weekly basis.

And that treat, my friends, is a cookie.




Not just any cookie, but a huge cookie. A huge, thick, semidry, jaw-straining oatmeal raisin cookie, courtesy of Breezy Hill Orchard and Cider Mill, via the Union Square Greenmarket.

This is a sink-your-teeth-in kind of baked good: It gives your chompers a run for their money, which is just how I like my baked goods to be. It's almost the texture of a very dense protein bar. (Which is not to imply that I fool myself into thinking it's a "healthy" cookie. A cookie's a cookie, man -- even if it does happen to be a workout for your molars.)

And because it's sweetened with apple sauce instead of sugar, it isn't at all cloying. In fact, it's much more oaty and cinnamony than anything else, though the raisins get terrifically juicy and tend to pop like little bursts of jelly candy when bitten into.


It's become my Saturday-morning ritual to walk the dog out Greenmarket way on the hunt for one of these baked forces of nature. Though Breezy Hill is at the market other days of the week, something about a molar-challenging oatmeal-raisin cookie just screams "Let's start this weekend!" to me for some reason, so I refrain from workweek indulgences on the things.

It ain't easy, let me tell you. I seriously love these delicious little hockey-puck-esque things. It's inexplicable!


Now all I have to do is learn how to re-create them. Then we'd be getting into some trouble, people.

Do you have a regular favorite treat? (Hopefully, unlike me, you don't have to wait for a particular day of the week to enjoy it…)

10 comments:

  1. do you think you'll attempt to recreate these gems in your kitchen?

    my fave weekend treat: going to the cafe around the corner & getting a large iced coffee with soy milk & dumping about 7 packets of raw cane sugar, stirring it minimally. i want the sugar to fall to the bottom so that when i sip thru my straw, i get a mouth full of sugar, pull up the straw a bit and sip the coffee. it's something that i learned when i had a roommate from Iran. they hold sugar cubes btwn their teeth and sip their coffee thru it. it's like candy and i'm such a child about it.

    ReplyDelete
  2. @Angry Asian I might have to try to re-create them -- except then I'll just eat them all the time! That's the problem with baking…

    And I'm kind of with you on the sweet drinkable treats. I love going to Persian restaurants and getting tea at the end of the meal; there's nothing as lovely as topping off a great dinner with a hot cup of fresh tea drunk sipped sweetly through a sugar cube. Yum! 

    ReplyDelete
  3. I love the Union Square market! And hey, molars and jaws have to work out too! I have lots of favorite treats, but like you, I try to restrict my indulgences to the weekend. Otherwise I would have to roll to work.

    ReplyDelete
  4. @Nuts about food Every once in a while I find an excuse to swing by the Greenmarket on a day other than Saturday to see if Breezy Hill is there... thankfully they're often out of cookies when I get there!

    ReplyDelete
  5. If you want to try to make these, know the apple sauce actually replaces the butter, I usually make my chocolate chip cookies with 1/2 applesauce and 1/2 butter as just applesauce makes them runny, with the oats this won't be as much of a problem. Also you could use avocado to replace the butter. Only trick for you is to determine the amount of apple juice to use to replace the sugar, tasting as you go should work. ;)

    ReplyDelete
  6. @Lara Oh, no! Don't reveal all the mysteries of re-creating these cookies to me: I'll just bake them and eat them all, putting myself into a cookie coma. We wouldn't want that!

    ReplyDelete
  7. These sounds like one heck of a cookie - if I were closer to them, I'd probably make them a ritual of mine too!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Yum! I'll have to pick one of these up next time I stop by the Union Square Greenmarket! :)

    ReplyDelete
  9. @BigAppleNosh I hope you do -- and let me know if you like it!

    (Be sure to give your cookie a squeeze before buying it to make sure it's soft; they can sure be a beast if they're even a little bit stale, which can happen in the deep heat.)

    ReplyDelete
  10. @Peggy They're definitely the highlight of my week!

    ReplyDelete

Thanks so much for stopping by! Meister (aka the Nervous Cook) reads and appreciates every one of your comments.

Be sure to leave a link to your own blog, so everyone can check it out.